A travel management consultant advises a company on how its travel programme should be designed, bought and measured, and is paid a fee for that advice. A travel management company (TMC) is a business that books and services the trips themselves, and is paid through fees and supplier income. Most companies need both eventually, but the order matters: where no policy, spend data or supplier contract exists yet, the consultant is usually the better first purchase.

What each one sells

The two are often compared as if they were rival suppliers. They sell different things.

  • A TMC sells execution. It issues tickets, books hotels and cars, supports travellers when plans change, produces reports and, in most cases, provides an online booking tool (OBT), the software through which employees book within company rules.
  • A consultant sells judgement. The deliverables are documents and decisions: a travel policy, an analysis of existing spend, a tender, a negotiated supplier position, a recommendation on which TMC to appoint. See the scope of travel management consulting for companies for how this is typically structured.

A TMC will advise as part of its sales process, and some advice is useful. It is still advice from a party whose income depends on what the company books and how. That does not make it dishonest. It makes it interested, and the buyer should read it that way.

How a TMC is paid, and what the proposal tends to leave out

A TMC proposal leads with fees because fees are what buyers compare. Typical items are a management fee (a fixed monthly or annual charge for running the account) and a transaction fee (a charge per booking, often priced differently for online and offline bookings). These figures are real, but they are rarely the whole of the TMC's remuneration.

Other income streams commonly sit outside the headline fee:

  • Supplier incentives. Airlines, hotel chains and the global distribution systems (GDS, the networks that carry airline, hotel and car inventory to booking agents) can pay a TMC for volume or for steering bookings towards them. For background on how the network side works, see the explanation of Travelport and the GDS.
  • Hotel commission and rate structure. Some hotel bookings generate commission to the TMC, and the rate type chosen affects who earns what.
  • Ancillary charges. Implementation, reporting, after hours service, exchanges, refunds and ticketing can each carry a separate line.
  • Contract terms. Term length, exit conditions, data ownership and any obligation to use the TMC's preferred suppliers all change the real cost of the agreement.

The practical consequence is that a low transaction fee can sit alongside a high total cost, and a high fee can be offset by incentives that are passed back to the client. Neither is visible unless the buyer asks for the full remuneration model in writing, including what is retained and what is rebated. A TMC that answers this clearly is showing something useful about how it will behave later.

What a consultant sells, and where it stops

A consultant is usually paid a fixed project fee or a day rate. Because the fee does not depend on booking volume, the consultant has no financial reason to prefer one supplier, one channel or one level of spend. That independence is the main thing being bought.

Typical work includes:

  • Writing or revising the travel policy, the document that sets who may travel, at what class and at what price.
  • Analysing spend by supplier, route, city and booking channel to find where money leaks.
  • Preparing a request for proposal (RFP), the formal tender sent to TMCs or hotels, and scoring the replies.
  • Negotiating hotel and airline agreements, including terms such as last room availability (LRA), the clause that holds the negotiated rate even when a hotel is nearly full. The mechanics are covered in the guide to negotiated, dynamic and LRA hotel rates.
  • Setting out a duty of care framework: the employer's obligation to protect the safety and wellbeing of people travelling on its behalf, including how it will locate and contact them in an incident.

The limits are as important. A consultant does not book trips and does not run a round the clock service desk. Independence also varies. Some consultants receive referral payments from the TMCs they recommend, and a buyer should ask, plainly, whether any such arrangement exists before accepting a shortlist.

When a consultant is the better first purchase

Advice should come before a booking contract in these situations:

  • There is no written policy. A TMC will configure its tools around whatever rules exist. If none exist, it configures around its own defaults.
  • Spend is not visible. Without a baseline, the company cannot judge whether a proposal saves anything, and cannot hold a supplier to a target.
  • A multi year TMC contract is about to be signed. Exit terms, data ownership and remuneration disclosure are far easier to settle before signature than after.
  • The programme is growing quickly. Volume gives bargaining power, and a consultant can help the company use it before the first agreement fixes the terms.
  • Nobody in the company owns travel. A consultant can define the role and the processes so that a hire or an internal appointment has something to work from.

When a TMC comes first

A TMC is the right first purchase when the immediate need is operational. A company with a small number of trips each month, no pressing cost problem and no one to book them often needs a booking service and emergency support this week, not a strategy document. The sensible way to do this is to keep the contract short, ask for the data in a usable format from the first month, and commission advice later, once there is spend to analyse.

The wider question of whether a company needs an agency at all, or whether an internal role is enough, is set out in the comparison of a travel agency and a travel coordinator.

Questions to put to either party

These questions apply to a TMC and to a consultant, and the quality of the answers is informative in both cases.

  • How are you paid in total, and by whom?
  • Which payments depend on where our travellers book or how much they spend?
  • Who owns the booking data, and in what format can we take it away?
  • What happens to the contract if we leave after twelve months?
  • Which of your recommendations would reduce your own income?

The last question is the most revealing. A consultant with no volume based income can usually answer it with an example. A TMC can answer it too, but the answer needs to be tested against the contract.

The internal role that connects the two

Whichever supplier is chosen, someone inside the company still has to manage the relationship, check invoices, enforce policy and handle exceptions. That is the work of a travel coordinator, and the contents of the role are described in the travel coordinator job description. A company that has a consultant's policy, a TMC's service and no internal owner will usually find the arrangement drifts within a year.